2024-25 Indians Wrestling
Final Record: 17-9
8th Place District 6
3rd Place Big North-Liberty
| Date | 2024-2025 Schedule | Results |
| 12/17 | Rutherford | L 30-51 |
| 12/21 | Clifton Tournament | 5th |
| 12/28 | Lenape Valley Tournament | 5th |
| 12/30 | @ Passaic County Tech (PCTI) | L 12-53 |
| 12/30 | Ramsey @ PCTI | W 56-23 |
| 1/4 | @ Wallkill Valley | W 43-35 |
| 1/4 | North Plainfield @ Wallkill Valley | L 31-44 |
| 1/8 | @ Paramus | L 23-41 |
| 1/10 | Manchester Regional | L 31-36 |
| 1/11 | Pioneer Academy | W 77-6 |
| 1/11 | Indian Hills | W 42-33 |
| 1/11 | Pequannock | W 46-29 |
| 1/13 | Fort Lee | W 40-37 |
| 1/15 | Dwight Morrow | W 64-13 |
| 1/15 | Paterson Eastside | W 77-6 |
| 1/17 | @ Teaneck | W 55-40 |
| 1/18 | @ Clifton | L 12-49 |
| 1/18 | JFK Paterson @ Clifton | W 71-10 |
| 1/25 | Passaic County Tournament  |
11th |
| 1/29 | @ Madison | W 30-29 |
| 1/31 | Dumont | W 47-23 |
| 2/1 | Weehawken | W 65-6 |
| 2/5 | Newark East Side | W 39-29 |
| 2/8 | Secaucus | L 35-37 |
| 2/8 | Kearny | L 23-50 |
| 2/8 | Weehawken | W 72-6 |
| 2/10 | PCTI N1 G5 First Round | L 34-42 |
| 2/12 | Orange | W 48-27 |
| 2/14 | Bergenfield | W 41-30 |
| 2/22 | District 6 Tournament | 8th |
2023-2024 Indians Wrestling
Final Record: 15-12
8th Place District 5
3rd Place – Big North Liberty Division
| Date | 2023-2024 Schedule | Results |
| 12/15 | @ Wayne Hills | L 12-60 |
| 12/16 | Clifton Holiday Tournament | 2nd |
| 12/20 | Clifton | L 21-55 |
| 12/27 | @ Newark East Side | W 34-33 |
| 12/27 | Montclair @ Newark East Side | W 57-16 |
| 12/28 | Lenape Valley Invitational | 13th |
| 12/30 | @ PCTI | L 9-63 |
| 12/30 | Eastside @ PCTI | W 54-15 |
| 1/3 | West Milford | L 12-64 |
| 1/5 | @ DePaul | W 33-28 |
| 1/6 | @ Wallkill Valley | W 41-34 |
| 1/6 | North Plainfield @ Wallkill Valley | L 39-40 |
| 1/6 | Weehawken @ Wallkill Valley | W 59-15 |
| 1/10 | JFK Paterson | W 72-11 |
| 1/12 | @ Indian Hills | W 36-31 |
| 1/13 | @ Garfield | W 36-24 |
| 1/13 | Teaneck @ Garfield | L 36-37 |
| 1/17 | @ Lyndhurst | L 34-37 |
| 1/17 | Leonia @ Lyndhurst | L 25-47 |
| 1/20 | Passaic County Tournament | 11th |
| 1/24 | Passaic Valley | L 12-68 |
| 1/27 | @ Wood-Ridge | L 33-35 |
| 1/27 | Newark Collegiate @ Wood-Ridge | W 63-15 |
| 1/27 | Bogota @ Wood-Ridge | L 33-42 |
| 2/5 | Clifton N1 G5 Quarterfinals | L 27-43 |
| 2/7 | Dwight Morrow | W 71-4 |
| 2/8 | @ Orange | W 51-21 |
| 2/10 | Manchester | W 36-33 |
| 2/10 | New Brunswick | W 56-21 |
| 2/10 | Trenton Central | W 33-30 |
| 2/17 | District 5 Tournament | 8th |
2022-2023 Indians Wrestling
| Date | 2022-2023 Schedule | Results |
| 12/16 | Wayne Hills | L 18-63 |
| 12/17 | Clifton Tournament | 4th |
| 12/21 | @ Clifton | L 18-65 |
| 12/27 | @ Passaic Valley | L 18-57 |
| 1/4 | @ West Milford | L 6-73 |
| 1/7 | Wallkill Valley | L 30-51 |
| 1/7 | Weehawken | W 55-15 |
| 1/9 | Frisch | W 45-33 |
| 1/11 | @ JFK Paterson | W 69-7 |
| 1/13 | River Dell @ Big North Conference Duals | L 6-73 |
| 1/13 | Fair Lawn @ Big North Conference Duals | L 16-63 |
| 1/14 | Wayne Valley @ Big North Conference Duals | L 0-79 |
| 1/14 | Lakeland @ Big North Conference Duals | L 33-48 |
| 1/18 | PCTI | L 3-76 |
| 1/21 | Passaic County Tournament |
13th |
| 1/25 | Garfield |
W 39-36 |
| 1/25 | Eastside | W 49-21 |
| 1/28 | Union |
W 48-25 |
| 1/28 | Franklin | L 14-64 |
| 1/28 | Bernards | L 9-69 |
| 1/31 | @ Whippany Park | W 48-24 |
| 1/31 | Hopatcong @ Whippany Park | W 66-9 |
| 2/1 | @ DePaul | L 27-42 |
| 2/3 | @ Columbia | L 30-39 |
| 2/3 | Teaneck @ Columbia | W 51-27 |
| 2/6 | PCTI North 1 Group 5 First Round |
L 21-51 |
| 2/7 | Orange | W 61-15 |
| 2/8 | @ Newark Eastside | L 30-36 |
| 2/11 | @ Dover | W 39-34 |
| 2/11 | Asbury Park @ Dover | W 46-27 |
| 2/11 | Lakewood @ Dover | L 29-42 |
| 2/18 | District 5 Tournament | 6th |
