2023-24 Mustangs Wrestling
Final Record: 20-5
North 1, Group 5 Sectional Champion
2nd Place District 5
2nd Place – Big North Liberty Division
| Date | 2023-2024 Schedule | Results |
| 12/15 | Fair Lawn | W 60-15 |
| 12/16 | Clifton Holiday Tournament | 1st |
| 12/20 | @ Passaic | W 55-21 |
| 12/22 | Morris Hills | L 18-46 |
| 12/28 | Sam Cali Tournament | 15th |
| 12/29 | Par Hills Holiday Tournament | 9th |
| 1/3 | JFK Paterson | W 72-12 |
| 1/5 | @ Old Tappan | W 42-33 |
| 1/6 | @ Bloomfield | W 54-21 |
| 1/6 | Westfield @ Bloomfield | W 57-21 |
| 1/6 | Teaneck @ Bloomfield | W 54-24 |
| 1/10 | Eastside | W 78-6 |
| 1/12 | Pascack Hills @ Big North Duals | W 57-21 |
| 1/13 | Old Tappan @ Big North Duals | L 27-46 |
| 1/13 | PCTI @ Big North Duals | L 24-45 |
| 1/20 | Passaic County Tournament | 8th |
| 1/24 | @ Ridgewood | W 48-17 |
| 1/26 | PCTI | L 31-38 |
| 1/27 | @ West Milford | W 48-24 |
| 1/27 | North Warren @ West Milford | W 58-22 |
| 1/27 | Depaul @ West Milford | W 40-38 |
| 1/31 | Kearny | W 53-24 |
| 2/3 | @ Elmwood Park | W 48-24 |
| 2/3 | Glen Ridge @ Elmwood Park | W 49-17 |
| 2/3 | Fort Lee @ Elmwood Park | W 69-12 |
| 2/5 | Passaic N1 G5 Quarterfinals | W 43-27 |
| 2/5 | North Bergen N1 G5 Semifinals | W 40-33 |
| 2/7 | @ PCTI N1 G5 Finals | W 32-31 |
| 2/9 | Phillipsburg G5 Semifinals | L 9-65 |
| 2/17 | District 5 Tournament | 2nd |
2022-2023 Mustangs Wrestling
| Date | 2022-2023 Schedule | Results |
| 12/16 | @ Fair Lawn | W 63-15 |
| 12/17 | Clifton Tournament | 1st |
| 12/21 | Passaic | W 65-18 |
| 12/28 | @ Par Hills Tournament | 3rd |
| 1/4 | JFK Paterson | W 84-0 |
| 1/6 | Old Tappan | L 36-43 |
| 1/7 | @ Bloomfield | W 42-24 |
| 1/7 | Westfield @ Bloomfield | L 27-50 |
| 1/7 | Teaneck @ Bloomfield | W 76-6 |
| 1/11 | Paterson Eastside | W 84-0 |
| 1/13 | Demarest @ Big North Duals | W 52-19 |
| 1/13 | Pascack Hills @ Big North Duals | W 44-18 |
| 1/14 | Old Tappan @ Big North Duals  |
W 39-32 |
| 1/14 | PCTI @ Big North Duals |
W 36-33 |
| 1/18 | @ Princeton | W 60-23 |
| 1/21 | Passaic County Tournament |
1st |
| 1/25 | @ PCTI |
L 30-36 |
| 1/27 | @ River Dell | W 33-32 |
| 1/28 | West Milford | W 39-33 |
| 1/28 | North Warren | W 63-15 |
| 1/28 | DePaul | W 60-24 |
| 2/1 | @ Kearny | W 63-13 |
| 2/4 | @ Elmwood Park | W 58-19 |
| 2/4 | Garfield @ Elmwood Park | W 70-6 |
| 2/4 | Fort Lee @ Elmwood Park | W 69-6 |
| 2/6 | West Orange North 1 Group 5 First Round | W 39-36 |
| 2/6 | Livingston North 1 Group 5 Semifinals | W 37-36 |
| 2/8 | PCTI North 1 Group 5 Finals |
L 31-33 |
| 2/18 | District 5 Tournament | 3rd |
