2025-2026 Pirates Wrestling
| Date | 2025-2026 Schedule | Results |
| 12/10 | @ Irvington | W 75-6 |
| 12/13 | Southern Tournament | No Places |
| 12/17 | Nutley | W 62-10 |
| 12/20 | Morris Knolls Tournament | 10th |
| 12/21 | Beast of East (Del) | Tie 17th |
| 12/27 | Sam Cali | 12th |
| 1/2 | CBA @ Catholic School Duals | L 25-45 |
| 1/2 | Immaculata @ Catholic School Duals | W 44-26 |
| 1/3 | RBC @ Catholic School Duals | L 24-37 |
| 1/3 | St. John Vianney @ Catholic School Duals | W 48-24 |
| 1/7 | @ Caldwell | W 51-23 |
| 1/10 | New Providence | W 78-4 |
| 1/10 | Bound Brook | W 74-4 |
| 1/10 | Middletown North | W 39-28 |
| 1/14 | @ West Essex | W 41-22 |
| 1/17-1/18 | Escape the Rock Tournament | 34th |
| 1/23 | Essex County Tournament | 1st |
| 1/28 | Cedar Grove | W 55-12 |
| 1/30 | Livingston | W 64-6 |
| 2/7 | St. Joes (Met) | W 43-21 |
| 2/7 | Toms River East | W 49-17 |
| 2/17 | St. Augustine Non-Public A First Round | W 34-29 |
| 2/17 | CBA Non-Public A Quarterfinals | L 9-53 |
| 2/28 | District 24 Tournament | 1st |
For Seton Hall Prep results from 2024-25 and earlier, click here
| Head Coach: Lou Mascola |
| Colors: Royal Blue, White |
| Section: Non-Public A |
| District: 24 |
| Region: 6 |
Program History
State Champions
| 2012-Brenden Calas-113 |
| 2011-Brenden Calas-103 |
| 1979-Joe Spinazzola-108 |
| 1972-Tom Arminio-106 |
| 1971-Dante Caprio-148 |
| 1968-Herb Campbell-136 |
| 1963-Fred Buechel-136 |
State Place Winners
| 2025-Anthony Pellegrino-120/7th |
| 2025-Rocco Salerno-215/8th |
| 2024-Logan Brzozowski-120/5th |
| 2024-Rocco Salerno-215/7th |
| 2023-Logan Brzozowski-113/2nd |
| 2022-Joseph Sciarrone-113/4th |
| 2021-Conner Decker-182/4th |
| 2021-Jack Wilt-195/3rd |
| 2020-Michael Massa-195/6th |
| 2017-Aidan Monteverdi-170/4th |
| 2013-Brenden Calas-120/2nd |
| 2011-Lou Mascola-135/6th |
| 2009-Lou Mascola-119/5th |
| 2005-Angelo DiLeo-171/8th |
| 2004-Jack Decker-140/2nd |
| 2004-Angelo DiLeo-160/8th |
| 2003-Jack Decker-125/6th |
| 2001-Kevin Bryan-135/6th |
| 1996-Donnie DeFilippis-112/2nd |
| 1987-Mike O’Neill-136/6th |
| 1986-Chris DeGrazia-116/2nd |
| 1983-Pat Smith-149/4th |
| 1979-Mike Deehan-129/3rd |
| 1978-Joe Spinazzola-101/2nd |
| 1977-Paul Deehan-108/3rd |
| 1977-Jack Gross-148/4th |
| 1974-Greg Cunningham-108/3rd |
| 1971-Paul Natale-141/2nd |
| 1971-Manny Almedia-157/2nd |
| 1970-Angelo Almedia-168/4th |
| 1963-Greg Smith-Hwt/4th |
| 1962-Ed Bilinski-168/2nd |
| 1955-Mal Forrester-136/4th |
Region Champions
| 2024-Logan Brzozowski-120 |
| 2021-Joseph Sciarrone-113 |
| 2021-Jack Wilt-195 |
